Creamsicle Slushy Orange Yogurt

Nothing says summer quite like a frosty creamsicle slushy made with real orange juice and creamy vanilla yogurt. This recipe blends up into an instant throwback to those icy push-pops from your childhood and requires only a few common ingredients. It is my go-to for hot afternoons when you want that classic orange and vanilla combination without the mess or fuss of homemade ice cream.

I started making these for neighborhood cookouts and now they have become the first thing my friends request whenever the temperature rises. There is nothing like seeing everyone’s faces light up when you bring out a pitcher of homemade slushy.

Ingredients

• Orange juice: Brings sweet citrus flavor and turns into ice cubes for the perfect texture. Choose a juice with no added sugar or fresh squeezed if you can.
• Vanilla bean yogurt: Adds creaminess and rich vanilla notes. Greek yogurt makes it extra thick but any style works. Look for brands with real vanilla for the best taste.
• Honey: Naturally sweetens and balances the tart orange. Use a mild honey for a clean flavor. For substitutions try agave or skip it if your orange juice is already quite sweet.

Instructions

Prepare Orange Juice Ice:

Pour one and one third cups of orange juice into an ice cube tray filling each space almost to the top. Freeze until completely solid which usually takes at least three hours. This transforms your orange juice into the slushy base that blends smoothly.

Blend the Slushy:

Once the juice cubes are fully frozen tip all of them into your blender. Add the remaining one third cup of orange juice along with both containers of vanilla bean yogurt and the tablespoon of honey. Blend on high until no chunks remain and the slushy is creamy and frosty. Stop to scrape down the sides if needed for an even blend.

Taste and Adjust:

Dip in a spoon and check the sweetness. If you like it sweeter drizzle in a touch more honey and blend once more. For a grownup version pour in a splash of vodka or rum and give it one last whirl.

Serve Immediately:

Pour your slushy into cold glasses straight from the blender. The texture is best right away—icy, creamy, and soft like a frosted shake.

Pin it

My favorite part of this recipe is how the honey and vanilla combine to taste exactly like that classic creamsicle flavor from the ice cream truck. For me there is a bit of nostalgia every time I make a batch and listen to the blender whir while the kids gather around waiting for the first glass.

Storage Tips

Creamsicle slushies are best consumed right away for maximum frosty texture. If you have leftovers pour them into popsicle molds and freeze. This way you have homemade creamsicle pops ready for another day. Stored slushy in the fridge will become liquid and lose its signature texture so I always try to finish them the same day.

Ingredient Substitutions

You can swap the vanilla yogurt for a dairy-free coconut yogurt to make the recipe vegan. If you are out of honey use a splash of maple syrup. The flavor will change slightly but the creamy texture remains. Plain yogurt with a splash of vanilla extract also works in a pinch.

Serving Suggestions

Garnish with a twist of orange peel or a sprig of mint for a fancy touch. For parties I like to set up a slushy bar with mix-ins like berries or mango cubes. My kids love it when I let them add mini chocolate chips for an extra treat.

Cultural and Historical Context

The original creamsicle treat dates back to the 1930s when it debuted as a frozen orange pop with a creamy vanilla center. This homemade version gives you the same iconic taste using real ingredients instead of artificial flavors. Making slushies at home was always a highlight during summer break in my childhood and these are still a happy tradition in my house.

Pin it

With just a handful of ingredients and a blender you can enjoy the tastes of summer at any time. Each sip is creamy, nostalgic, and perfect for cooling off on a hot day.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I use regular yogurt instead of Greek yogurt?

Yes, regular or Greek yogurt both work well. Greek yogurt gives a thicker texture while regular yogurt yields a lighter slushy.

→ How long should I freeze the orange juice?

Freeze orange juice in ice cube trays for about three hours, or until solid, to ensure a perfectly chilled blend.

→ Can I sweeten the slushy differently?

Honey adds subtle sweetness, but you can substitute maple syrup, agave, or leave out sweeteners for a tart finish.

→ How can I make this slushy for adults?

Add a splash of vodka or rum to the blender for a flavorful adult version. Serve immediately for best taste.

→ Does the slushy store well in the freezer?

This slushy is best served right after blending. Freezing the mix changes the texture and may make it icy.