Homemade spreads and toppings

These condiment recipes have revolutionized my kitchen because they're all those little extras that make such a big difference and what makes them really special is how you can control exactly what goes into them whether you're making something spicy sweet or tangy plus they're always so much better than anything store bought and I love having a fridge full of homemade jars ready to add that perfect finishing touch to any dish and everyone always notices the difference when you use homemade condiments.

28 recipes in this collection. (Page 1 Of 3)
Updated on Sat, 11 Jan 2025 22:33:33 GMT

Condiment Recipes

Cowboy Candy candied jalapeños in syrup with cream cheese and crackers
Condiments Cowboy Candy (Candied Jalapeños) 4 Ratings

Sweet, spicy candied jalapeños simmered in a tangy brown sugar syrup and chilled until glossy and bold.

Pickled cherry tomatoes, red onions, and cucumbers in brine
Condiments Refrigerator Pickled Cherry Tomatoes, Red Onions, and Cucumbers 4 Ratings

Crunchy cucumbers, juicy cherry tomatoes, and pink red onions in a quick garlic dill brine for snacking, salads, sandwiches, and bowls.

Strawberry jalapeno jam spooned over cream cheese with crackers
Condiments Sweet Heat with Jalapeno and Strawberry Jam 21 Ratings

A glossy sweet-spicy strawberry jalapeno jam made with ripe berries, fresh peppers, pectin, and a safe water-bath finish.

Glossy cowboy candy jalapeño rings in a glass jar with syrup
Condiments Cowboy Candy with Sweet and Spicy Jalapeños 24 Ratings

Glossy candied jalapeño rings in a sweet, tangy syrup with steady heat and plenty of ways to serve them.

Jar of ruby watermelon lime preserves with a spoonful on the rim
Condiments Refreshing Watermelon Lime Preserves for Summer 22 Ratings

Bright watermelon preserves with fresh lime, made in one pot and ready for the fridge. A small-batch summer project that tastes like sunshine.

Tangy bread and butter pickles with golden brine in a glass mason jar
Condiments Tangy Bread and Butter Pickles with Crunchy Cucumbers 20 Ratings

Sweet and tangy bread and butter pickles made with crunchy cucumbers, ready in a couple of hours. Perfect for sandwiches, burgers, and snacking straight from the jar.

Golden pineapple jalapeño chutney in a glass jar with chips and cilantro
Condiments Fresh Spicy Pineapple Jalapeño Chutney with Tropical Heat 12 Ratings

Fresh pineapple, jalapeños, lime, ginger, and vinegar simmer into a glossy sweet-heat chutney for grilled meats, tacos, cheese boards, and snacks.

Sweet tangy rhubarb butter in a jar with toast and fresh rhubarb
Condiments How to Make Sweet Tangy Rhubarb Butter 11 Ratings

A smooth, sweet tangy rhubarb butter made with fresh rhubarb, lemon, sugar, and vanilla for toast, yogurt, biscuits, and desserts.

Golden Italian lemon jam with citrus peel in a glass jar
Condiments Italian Lemon Jam with a Citrus Twist 19 Ratings

A glossy Italian-style lemon jam with orange and grapefruit for a bright sweet-tart citrus spread.

Torshi Seer garlic pickle with dark vinegar brine and soft cloves
Condiments Torshi Seer (Garlic Pickle) 8 Ratings

A simple Persian garlic pickle made with whole garlic heads, vinegar, salt, and time until mellow, tangy, and soft.

Ruby-red Sriracha Salt in a small white bowl with scattered grains
Condiments Sriracha Salt 10 Ratings

A spicy, tangy finishing salt made with coarse salt and sriracha, dried low and slow until crisp.

Glossy lime marmalade in a glass jar with toast and fresh limes
Condiments Lime Marmalade Recipe Without Pectin 16 Ratings

A bright, tangy lime marmalade made without boxed pectin, with tender peel and a glossy old-fashioned set.