Pin it
Get ready for pure comfort with this satisfying Sloppy Joe Grilled Cheese mashup. Every bite is packed with melty cheese, sweet and savory Sloppy Joe meat, and crisp, buttery bread that's toasted to perfection.
This sandwich was my go-to when my kids refused to eat anything. It started as a sneaky way to use leftovers, but now everybody begs for it. Especially on those hectic nights when we're hungry but don't have much time to cook.
Cheesy Ingredients
- American cheese slices: Perfectly melts and adds a creamy, mild flavor that doesn't overpower the Sloppy Joe meat
- White bread: Go for thicker slices so your sandwich stays sturdy and crisps up nicely
- Butter: Softened makes it easy to coat every inch of the bread for that awesome golden crunch
- Prepared Sloppy Joe meat: Use a thick mix, whether you make it from scratch or grab a mix from the store—it just shouldn't be too runny
- Fun extras (optional): Throw in slices of dill pickles or jalapeños for a punch of extra flavor
Epic How-To for Sloppy Joe Grilled Cheese
- Chill the filling first:
- Let your Sloppy Joe mixture cool a bit before you start. That way it doesn't turn your sandwich into a melty mess. Get everything else set up on the counter so you can move fast.
- Ready your skillet:
- Heat your pan or griddle on medium. Cast iron works like magic for nice, even toasting. Let it warm up for at least three minutes before you start.
- Slather on that butter:
- Coat one side of each bread slice with soft butter—make sure to hit every edge so your bread will brown up all over.
- Start the sandwich base:
- Drop the first slice of bread butter side down on the hot pan. Lay one slice of American cheese on it right away. That first bit of heat starts melting it and gives a good base to hold the filling.
- Layer on the meat:
- Scoop about three tablespoons of Sloppy Joe meat over the cheese, spreading it but keeping the edges clear so it doesn't spill out when cooking.
- Top it off:
- Add a second slice of cheese on top of the Sloppy Joe mix. Cap it with the other bread slice, buttered side facing up.
- Grill the first side:
- Toast without touching for about 3–4 minutes. Peek underneath sometimes so you don’t burn it—you’re going for golden brown, so turn down the heat if you need to.
- Flip it over:
- Slide your spatula under the sandwich and turn it carefully. If some meat tries to slip out, just tuck it back in. Be gentle but quick.
- Finish the other side:
- Cook for around 3 minutes. The bread should be seriously golden, and everything inside should be gooey and hot.
- Slice and eat:
- Move your grilled cheese to a cutting board and wait a minute before slicing. It helps everything stay together so you don’t lose all the filling.
Pin it
It's become a family thing: when we watch movies together, these grilled sandwiches show up with homemade chips on the side. The tangy beef, melty cheese, and crispy, buttered bread always disappear fast. Even my husband—who usually hates messy food—can’t say no to these.
Simple Make Ahead Options
Whip up your Sloppy Joe filling a few days ahead of time and pop it in the fridge—it'll hold up for three days. That way, when the hangry crowd shows up, you just slap the sandwiches together and grill. Cooled filling actually works better so the bread doesn’t get soggy. It turns dinner into a five-minute fix during super busy evenings.
Delicious Variations
The basic version rocks, but try mixing it up once in a while. Swap the American cheese for pepper jack if you like heat. Sourdough bread is awesome if you want a little tang. For some crunch, toss in some corn chips with your meat before you assemble everything. I’m a fan of layering in some dill pickle slices—they cut through the richness like magic.
Pin it
Winning Serving Suggestions
These sandwiches taste great with sides that keep things simple. Pour a light vinaigrette over a green salad for something fresh. Pile some potato chips or sweet potato fries on the plate for crunch. Want more comfort food? Dunk each bite in warm tomato soup—it’s next level. When it’s hot out, pair with a bowl of fruit salad for a sweet, juicy break from the savory sandwich.
Storage Tips
If you don’t eat every sandwich right away, stash leftovers in the fridge for up to two days. Wrap each one in foil or slide them into an airtight box. To warm up, use a 350°F oven or toaster oven for about 10 minutes. Skip the microwave if you like your bread crisp. Freeze extra Sloppy Joe meat for up to three months so you’re always ready for a quick sandwich later.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → How do you prevent the bread from burning?
Keep the heat on medium and make sure you spread butter evenly. Skip cranking it up too high and you’ll keep it from burning.
- → Can I use a different cheese?
Absolutely! Swap out American for cheddar, mozzarella, or really any cheese that'll melt nicely.
- → What type of bread works best?
White bread gets super crispy and holds everything well, but sourdough or whole wheat are good options too if you’re up for a switch.
- → Can I prepare the filling in advance?
For sure—fix the Sloppy Joe meat ahead and just keep it chilled for up to three days. That way, things move faster when it’s time to eat.
- → How do I make it less greasy?
Go easy on the butter or give the bread a light mist with cooking spray. That’ll tone down the heaviness a bit.
- → Can I add vegetables to the sandwich?
You bet! Throw on some pickles, add caramelized onions, or even toss in roasted peppers to shake things up.