Save it
In my kitchen these Peanut Butter Thumbprint Cookies bring pure joy with every batch. The way rich peanut butter cookies cradle those perfect chocolate kisses creates something magical. Every time I make them the aroma of fresh-baked peanut butter fills my home bringing back sweet holiday memories.
Pure Cookie Magic
What I love most about these cookies is how they bring together two perfect flavors in one bite. That soft peanut butter base with its chocolate crown needs no chilling time making them perfect for spontaneous baking with my kids. They disappear almost as quickly as we can make them.
What You'll Need
- Flour: Measured just right for that perfect tender crumb.
- Baking Powder: Creates those perfectly puffy cookies.
- Butter: I use unsalted to control the flavor balance.
- Sugar Blend: Both kinds for the perfect sweetness.
- Peanut Butter: The creamy kind works best here.
- Egg: Holds everything together beautifully.
- Kisses: Have them ready to go unwrapped.
Let's Start Baking
- Mix Your Base
- I start with those dry ingredients getting them perfectly blended.
- Create the Magic
- The peanut butter mixture gets so creamy and light.
- Bring It Together
- Mixing everything gently creates that perfect dough.
- Time to Shape
- Rolling these little balls is pure joy they bake up beautifully.
- Crown Them
- Working quickly with those kisses creates picture-perfect cookies.
Mix It Up
Sometimes I love getting creative with these cookies. A little melted chocolate and cream makes a wonderful ganache center or I'll fill them with my favorite jam. Each variation brings its own special charm especially when I use strawberry or raspberry preserves.
Save it
Keeping Them Fresh
These cookies stay wonderful in an airtight container for several days though they rarely last that long in my house. When I'm planning ahead I'll freeze a batch they keep beautifully as long as they're packed carefully to protect those chocolate kisses.
Holiday Magic
There's something about these cookies that captures the spirit of holiday baking. Maybe it's how that peanut butter and chocolate combination brings back childhood memories or how their festive look brightens any cookie tray. They've become such a special part of our celebrations.
Perfect Balance
I've found that making these cookies just the right size creates the perfect bite. Every taste includes that wonderful combination of soft peanut butter cookie and creamy chocolate kiss. It's what makes them so irresistible.
My Best Tips
Measuring the flour carefully makes such a difference in texture. I always use regular creamy peanut butter natural just doesn't work the same way. Having those kisses unwrapped and ready to go is essential they need to meet those warm cookies right away.
Family Time
Making these cookies has become one of our favorite family activities. The kids love helping unwrap kisses and roll dough balls. There's something special about creating these together making memories that are as sweet as the cookies themselves.
Different Flavors
Sometimes we'll use dark chocolate kisses or make centers from white chocolate. That thumbprint is like a little canvas for creativity whether filled with chocolate or jam. Each batch can be a new adventure.
Time-Tested Favorite
These cookies have earned their place in my recipe collection. The simple ingredients and joyful process of making them never gets old. They're proof that sometimes the classics really are the best especially during the holidays.
Save it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → When should I add the Hershey Kisses?
Add the kisses immediately after taking cookies from the oven. They'll soften slightly but hold their shape as the cookies cool.
- → Why are my cookies spreading too much?
If cookies spread too much, the butter might be too warm. Try chilling the dough briefly or ensure butter is just melted, not hot.
- → Can I freeze these cookies?
Yes, freeze baked cookies without kisses for up to 3 months. Add kisses after thawing and slightly warming the cookies.
- → How do I get uniform cookie size?
Use a tablespoon measure or small cookie scoop for consistent sizing. Each cookie should be a scant tablespoon of dough.
- → Why unwrap kisses ahead of time?
Have kisses unwrapped before baking starts. You need to add them while cookies are hot, so being prepared is essential.