Save it
My Frosted Butter Pecan Cookies were born from memories of baking with my grandmother during the holidays. That magical combination of toasted pecans brown sugar and maple frosting creates something truly special. Every time I make these the kitchen fills with the most incredible buttery maple aroma and I'm transported back to those cozy baking days.
What Makes These Cookies Special
These aren't just any butter pecan cookies. The secret lies in browning some of the butter which adds this incredible nutty depth and combining it with maple-glazed pecans. They're perfectly sweet decadent enough to feel special but so easy to make. I love watching people's faces light up when they take their first bite.
Everything You'll Need
- Pecans: We're giving them the royal treatment toasting them with maple syrup brown sugar and cinnamon.
- Butter: One stick gets browned to golden perfection while the other stays creamy and soft.
- Brown Sugar: This gives us that perfect caramel note.
- Eggs: They bring everything together into perfect cookie dough.
- Vanilla: Just enough to enhance all those warm flavors.
- The Basics: Our flour baking soda and salt create the perfect structure.
- Dark Chocolate: Optional but amazing chunked up through the dough.
- For That Dreamy Frosting: Powdered sugar milk and more maple syrup create pure magic.
Save it
Let's Bake Together
- Starting with Our Pecans
- First we're going to transform those pecans into something incredible. As they simmer in maple syrup the kitchen starts smelling amazing. Once we add that brown sugar and cinnamon they become absolutely irresistible.
- The Butter Magic
- Now comes one of my favorite steps watching that butter turn golden brown. Keep a close eye on it when those little specks appear and it smells nutty that's our moment.
- Building Our Dough
- When we cream together our butter mixture and brown sugar it gets so light and fluffy. Then as each egg goes in the dough just gets better and better.
- Adding Our Treasures
- Folding in those maple glazed pecans and chocolate chunks feels like adding little jewels to our dough. I always save some pecans for the tops they make everything look so pretty.
- The Baking Dance
- That quick chill helps our cookies keep their shape. Then into the oven they go. That gentle tap on the pan after baking? It gives us those perfect crinkly edges.
- Creating Our Frosting
- The frosting comes together like silk smooth and creamy with that hint of maple.
- The Final Touch
- Dipping each cookie in that frosting and sprinkling those reserved pecans on top it's like putting the perfect finish on little works of art.
My Best Tips
After making these cookies countless times I've learned a few secrets. Watch that butter like a hawk when browning it can go from perfect to burnt in seconds. Don't skip the chilling step even five minutes makes a difference. And always always save your prettiest pecan pieces for decorating the tops.
Save it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I make these cookies ahead?
- Yes, they can be stored in an airtight container for up to 4 days. Let frosting set completely before storing.
- → Why freeze the dough balls before baking?
- The quick freeze helps prevent spreading during baking, ensuring the cookies keep their shape and texture.
- → What does browning the butter do?
- Browning butter adds a rich, nutty flavor that complements the pecans and maple. It makes the cookies more flavorful.
- → Can I skip the chocolate chips?
- Yes, the cookies are delicious with or without chocolate chips. You can omit them or replace with another mix-in.
- → Why tap the pan after baking?
- Tapping the pan helps flatten any domed cookies and creates that perfect cookie texture as they cool.