Pin it
Nothing brings back warm memories like biting into a hot peanut butter banana melt. This gooey, sweet, and crispy sandwich is a lifesaver around here for last-minute breakfasts or a little dessert after dinner. Creamy peanut butter, soft bananas, and crackly bread with a hint of mayo on the outside turn a simple childhood staple into something special.
I’m obsessed with the golden crunch from frying the mayo side on the bread. My grandma made it that way—never butter, always mayo! I totally get why and now do it every time I want the best crispy finish.
Irresistible Ingredients
- Mayonnaise: Swapping out butter for mayo makes the bread extra golden and adds a touch of savory. Full-fat is the way to go if you can.
- Plush white bread: Look for soft bakery loaves or anything fresh so your sandwich is pillowy and holds everything in.
- Ripe banana: Slice them up thin so they heat up sweet and gooey. Try to use bananas with some brown spots for max flavor.
- Creamy peanut butter: The silkier the better. If you’re using natural, give it a good stir to mix the oils back in.
Simple Instructions
- Let’s Get Grilling:
- Pop the sandwiches down mayo-side right on a preheated pan at medium-high. After about two minutes, when the outside is golden and crisp, flip and grill the other side for another couple minutes.
- Stack It Up:
- Once your banana and peanut butter are layered on two of the mayo-slathered bread slices, top them with the plain ones so the peanut butter is inside and mayo faces out.
- Let Them Rest:
- Give it just a moment or two before cutting—otherwise you’ll burn your mouth and the filling will ooze everywhere. Eat it straight away for max crunch.
- Get Your PB On:
- Spread peanut butter from edge to edge on the side of each slice that doesn't have mayo. Don’t hold back, you want every bite to be packed with flavor.
- Prepping the Bread:
- Take a spoon or spatula and coat just one side of every bread slice with an even layer of mayo. That’s your crust maker!
- Banana Goes Next:
- Lay banana coins over the peanut buttered bread—let them overlap a little so they melt together as it grills.
Pin it
When mornings are crazy, this is always our breakfast fix. After soccer, everyone grabs one too, since all the stuff for it’s already in the pantry. Once friends try it, they’re hooked.
Storage Tips
Chill extra sandwiches once they’ve cooled down. Wrap tight in foil. Stash in the fridge and eat within a day. Heat ‘em up in a skillet or toaster oven to get that snap back in the bread.
Ingredient Substitutions
Go with wheat or even sourdough bread if you want a little more flavor. Try cashew or almond butter if you’re out of peanut. For a swap, use honey in place of bananas for sweet vibes, but don’t skip out on the thick spread.
Serving Suggestions
Sip hot coffee or cocoa along with it and you’ll feel cozy. Try a dusting of cinnamon on the banana slices for extra warmth. Slice into sticks to make it kid-proof, or tuck ‘em in a lunchbox for later.
Cultural Context
Grilled peanut butter sandwiches are totally classic in the US, but the peanut butter banana version blew up because Elvis Presley was wild about it. That mayo trick? Straight from the South for the crunchiest bite.
Seasonal Adaptations
Spring calls for strawberries tucked in too, Autumn is perfect for thin apple slices and cinnamon, Winter? Go for thick whole grain bread for a bit more bite.
Success Stories
This sandwich keeps saving us during the weekday rush and is a post-game treat since the ingredients are always right there. Everyone asks how to make it after their first taste.
Freezer Meal Conversion
Make the sandwiches but don’t grill yet. Pop them flat into freezer bags, squeeze out all the air, and freeze. When hungry, grill straight from frozen—the outside will crisp up, and the inside melts in.
Pin it
This hot peanut butter banana melt is always a hit—great at breakfast or snack time. Enjoy it while still gooey and crispy for true comfort with every mouthful.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I use other types of bread?
For sure! Go for thick white bread, or mix it up with brioche or whole grain. Each kind gives the sandwich its own vibe and chew.
- → Why use mayonnaise on the bread?
Using mayo on the outside helps the bread crisp up and gives a little savory kick. It’s a neat trick for a better crust.
- → Is chunky peanut butter a good option?
Chunky peanut butter is great if you like a little crunch. Use whatever style you’re into—totally up to you.
- → Can I add other toppings or fillings?
Definitely. Toss in some chocolate chips, honey, or cinnamon if you want to sweeten things up. A pinch of sea salt can wake up the flavors too.
- → How do I avoid overcooking the sandwich?
Keep the heat at medium-high. Flip when each side turns golden. Watch closely so you don’t end up with burnt bread but get everything warm and melty inside.