Pin it
The luxurious combination of succulent lobster and rich, herb-infused Cowboy Butter creates an unforgettable dining experience. This recipe transforms already-special lobster tails into something truly extraordinary with a sauce that's packed with bold flavors and a subtle kick of heat.
I discovered this combination when experimenting with different compound butters for seafood. The moment I paired the smoky, herbed butter with sweet lobster meat, I knew I'd found something special. My guests always lean in for that first bite when they smell the aromatic butter hitting the hot grill.
Essential Ingredients Selection
- Fresh lobster tails: Look for ones that feel heavy for their size.
- Unsalted butter: Quality butter makes a huge difference in the sauce.
- Fresh herbs: Never substitute dried herbs here - fresh is essential.
- Smoked paprika: Use Spanish paprika for the most authentic flavor.
- Fresh lemons: The zest adds an extra layer of citrus flavor.
Detailed Grilling Method
- Prepare the lobster:
- Using sharp kitchen shears, cut through the top of the shell. Gently lift meat and place it on top of the shell. Pat dry thoroughly to ensure proper searing.
- Make the signature butter:
- Let butter soften naturally, don't microwave. Mix ingredients until well combined but don't overmix. Reserve one-third for finishing.
- Master the grilling technique:
- Clean and oil grates thoroughly. Place tails at a 45-degree angle to grates. Watch for color change at edges of the meat.
- Perfect the timing:
- Start flesh side down for good marking. Flip only once during cooking. Baste continuously with butter mixture.
Creating the Perfect Meal
I've learned that timing is everything with lobster. Having your side dishes ready before starting the grill ensures everything comes together perfectly.
Elevating Your Presentation
Consider serving the tails on a bed of grilled lemon slices with extra butter sauce in a warm ramekin alongside.
My dad, an experienced fisherman, taught me that the sweetest lobster meat comes from cooking it just until it turns opaque. Overcooking even a minute can make it tough.
Chef's Helpful Tips
- Bring lobster to room temperature before grilling.
- Keep a spray bottle of water handy for flare-ups.
- Create a foil shield for the tails if they brown too quickly.
This dish has become my go-to for special occasions. There's something magical about watching guests' eyes light up when they taste that first perfect bite of buttery, smoky lobster. It's more than just dinner - it's an experience that creates lasting memories around the table.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → How do I know when lobster is done?
- Lobster meat should be opaque white with no translucent gray areas and should easily pull away from the shell.
- → Can I make this without a grill?
- Yes! You can broil the lobster tails in your oven for similar results, about 4-5 minutes per side.
- → How do I split lobster tails?
- Use kitchen shears to cut through the top shell lengthwise, then slice through the meat, keeping the tail fin intact.
- → Can I make the sauce ahead?
- Yes, make the cowboy butter up to 3 days ahead. Just reheat gently before using.
- → What sides go well with this?
- Try grilled asparagus, cauliflower rice, or a fresh green salad to keep it low-carb.