Pin it
Irresistible Butterfinger Cheesecake Cupcakes are the kind of small dessert that disappears fast from a party tray. You get the dense creaminess of cheesecake, the snap of an Oreo crust, and that flaky peanut-butter candy crunch in every bite.
The batter is simple, but the texture depends on a few small choices. Soft cream cheese blends smooth, room-temperature eggs mix in gently, and a good chill gives the cupcakes their clean bakery-style shape.
Candy Crunch Cheesecake Lineup
Use brick-style cream cheese, not the whipped tub kind, because it bakes firmer and smoother. Chop the Butterfinger bars into mixed pieces so some melt into the filling while a few bigger shards stay crunchy on top.
- Oreo cookies. They make a dark, crisp base that balances the sweet peanut butter filling.
- Unsalted butter. Melted butter binds the cookie crumbs so each cupcake lifts cleanly from the liner.
- Cream cheese. Full-fat brick cream cheese gives the filling its rich body and smooth bite.
- Sour cream. A small scoop softens the sweetness and keeps the cheesecake tender.
- Creamy peanut butter. It deepens the candy flavor and turns into a quick drizzle for the top.
- Granulated sugar. Sugar sweetens the filling without making it gritty when mixed well.
- Eggs and yolk. They set the mini cheesecakes while keeping the centers plush.
- All-purpose flour. A spoonful helps stabilize the filling in the muffin tin.
- Vanilla extract. Vanilla rounds out the cream cheese and peanut butter.
- Butterfinger bars. Chopped candy brings flaky crunch, chocolate, and that toasted peanut-butter flavor.
- Confectioners' sugar. It thickens the warm peanut butter drizzle just enough to sit on top.
Bake The Mini Cheesecakes
- Prep the pan. Heat the oven and line a standard muffin tin with paper liners. A quick mist of baking spray helps the chilled cheesecakes release neatly.
- Make the crusts. Crush the cookies into fine crumbs, stir in melted butter, then press a spoonful firmly into each liner. Bake briefly so the crust sets before the filling goes in.
- Mix the filling. Beat the cream cheese, sour cream, peanut butter, sugar, and vanilla until smooth. Add the eggs and yolk on low speed, then fold in flour and chopped Butterfinger.
- Fill and bake. Spoon the batter over the crusts until the cups are nearly full. Bake until the edges are set and the centers still jiggle slightly.
- Cool and chill. Let the cupcakes cool in the pan, then refrigerate for at least 2 hours. Cold cheesecake holds its shape and tastes creamier.
- Top before serving. Warm the peanut butter gently, whisk in confectioners' sugar, then spoon a little over each chilled cupcake. Finish with chopped Butterfinger.
Keep The Filling Silky
Cold cream cheese is the main reason mini cheesecakes turn lumpy. Set the cream cheese, sour cream, eggs, and peanut butter on the counter before you start. They do not need to be warm. They just need to lose the refrigerator chill.
Once the eggs go in, slow down. Mix only until the batter looks even. Too much air makes the cupcakes puff high in the oven, then sink hard as they cool. A gentle batter bakes into a smooth top with a dense, creamy center.
The Crunch Needs Timing
Butterfinger pieces behave differently depending on where you put them. Folded into the batter, the small crumbs soften and flavor the cheesecake. Sprinkled on top right before serving, the larger pieces stay flaky and crisp. That split is why the cupcakes taste like candy without turning messy.
If you want more candy-bar desserts, try Butterfinger Bomb Cake Delight or the snackable Easy Butterfinger Puppy Chow. You can also check current candy details on the official Butterfinger site.
Swaps That Bake Cleanly
Chocolate sandwich cookies give the strongest crust, but graham crackers work if you want a lighter flavor. Use smooth commercial peanut butter for the filling. Natural peanut butter can separate and leave oily streaks in the cheesecake.
For a bigger dessert board, pair these with Cherry Cheesecake Cupcakes with Fresh Cherry Filling or Strawberry Cheesecake Red Velvet Cupcakes. The fruit versions cut through the richness nicely.
Chill, Store, And Serve
These cupcakes need refrigerator time. Two hours is the minimum, but overnight gives the cleanest texture. Store them covered in the fridge and wait to add the drizzle and candy until close to serving.
For food safety, keep dairy and egg-based desserts chilled when they are not being served. The FDA shares general storage guidance in its food safety resources. At home, I set these out for a short dessert window, then move extras back to the fridge.
Summary
These mini Butterfinger cheesecake cupcakes are rich, creamy, and easy to prep ahead. The best texture comes from softened dairy, gentle mixing, a short bake, and a full chill before topping.
FAQs
- Can I make Butterfinger cheesecake cupcakes ahead of time?
Yes. Bake and chill the cheesecake cupcakes up to 2 days ahead. Add the peanut butter drizzle and chopped candy the day you serve them so the topping stays crisp.
- Can I use graham crackers instead of Oreo cookies?
Yes. Use 1 cup fine graham cracker crumbs with 3 tablespoons melted butter. The crust will taste lighter and less chocolatey, but it still holds well after baking.
- Why did my cheesecake cupcakes crack?
Small cracks usually mean the batter was overmixed after the eggs went in or the cupcakes baked a little too long. They are still fine to eat. The drizzle and candy topping cover most surface cracks.
- How do I know when mini cheesecakes are done?
The edges should look set and slightly puffed, while the centers should still have a small wobble. They finish setting as they cool, then firm up fully in the refrigerator.
- Can I freeze these cheesecake cupcakes?
Freeze them without the drizzle or candy topping. Wrap the chilled cupcakes well and freeze for up to 1 month. Thaw overnight in the fridge, then top before serving.
- What can I serve with these cupcakes?
Serve them cold with coffee, milk, or a scoop of vanilla ice cream. For a dessert spread, pair them with fruit-forward treats like cherry or strawberry cheesecake cupcakes.
