Pin it
Creamy Amish Broccoli Salad is the kind of cold side dish that disappears first at a family table. It has crunchy raw broccoli, tender cauliflower pieces, salty bacon, sharp cheddar, and a dressing that is creamy, sweet, and lightly tangy.
I like it best after a short chill. The vegetables stay crisp, but the dressing softens the edges just enough. It is easy to carry to a potluck and sturdy enough to make a few hours ahead.
Creamy Amish Broccoli Salad Mix
Choose firm broccoli with tight green crowns and cauliflower without brown spots. The salad is simple, so crisp vegetables and good bacon make a real difference.
Cut everything small enough to fit on a fork. Big florets are hard to coat and harder to eat.
- Broccoli. Gives the salad its fresh crunch and earthy bite.
- Cauliflower. Adds a milder crunch that makes the bowl feel full and balanced.
- Bacon. Brings salt, smoke, and crisp bits through the creamy dressing.
- Sharp cheddar. Adds savory richness and a little tang.
- Red onion. Cuts through the dressing with a clean, sharp edge.
- Sunflower seeds. Add a nutty crunch that holds up after chilling.
- Raisins. Bring old-fashioned sweetness. Use dried cranberries if you like more tartness.
- Mayonnaise and sour cream. Make the dressing thick, creamy, and clingy.
- Sugar and apple cider vinegar. Create the sweet-tangy Amish-style dressing.
Chop, Dress, and Chill
- Cook the bacon. Fry it until crisp, then drain it well and crumble it into bite-size pieces.
- Cut the vegetables. Chop the broccoli and cauliflower into small florets. Slice large stems thinly if they are tender.
- Whisk the dressing. Stir mayonnaise, sour cream, sugar, vinegar, salt, and pepper until smooth. Taste it before it hits the vegetables.
- Toss the salad. Add broccoli, cauliflower, onion, raisins, sunflower seeds, cheddar, and most of the bacon to a large bowl. Fold in the dressing until everything is lightly coated.
- Chill and finish. Refrigerate for at least 30 minutes. Stir again, then top with the reserved bacon and a little extra cheddar before serving.
Keep the Crunch
The biggest mistake with this salad is cutting the vegetables too large or too wet. Wash the broccoli and cauliflower early if you can, then let them drain well. A salad spinner helps, but a clean towel works too. Water on the florets thins the dressing and leaves a puddle in the bowl.
Raw vegetables are what give this recipe its bite. If you prefer a gentler texture, pour boiling water over the chopped broccoli for 20 seconds, then rinse it cold and dry it very well. Do not fully blanch it or the salad starts to feel soft. For another crunchy take, try the site's Amish broccoli salad or the fruitier Honeycrisp apple broccoli salad.
Balance the Dressing
Classic Amish-style broccoli salad leans sweet, but it should not taste like dessert. Start with the sugar listed in the recipe, then adjust after whisking. The bacon and cheddar need a little sweetness around them. The vinegar keeps that sweetness from feeling heavy.
If you want a less sweet salad, reduce the sugar to 3 tablespoons. If your mayonnaise is very tangy, use the smaller amount of vinegar at first. Sour cream makes the dressing rounder and less oily than mayonnaise alone. Greek yogurt can stand in for the sour cream, but it will make the dressing sharper. Taste it with a piece of broccoli, not from the spoon, because the vegetables change how the dressing reads.
Make It for a Crowd
This is a dependable potluck salad because it does not wilt like lettuce. Double it in a very large bowl and toss with only three-quarters of the dressing at first. After chilling, add more only if the salad looks dry. That keeps the bottom from turning soupy on the buffet table.
For serving, scatter the last bacon and cheddar on top right before it goes out. It makes the bowl look fresh and gives the first spoonful a crisp bite. If you are building a cold side spread, pair it with Creamy Pasta Salad or Southern pea salad with creamy dressing.
Chill Time Helps
You can serve the salad right away, but 30 minutes in the fridge makes it taste more finished. The dressing clings better once it has cooled, and the onion loses some of its raw edge. Four hours is even better if your schedule allows it.
Keep the salad cold until serving. For general picnic and party handling, FoodSafety.gov recommends keeping cold foods cold and following the basic clean, separate, cook, and chill steps in its food safety guide. At home, store leftovers in an airtight container and stir them before serving again.
Add-Ins That Fit
Raisins are traditional in many broccoli salads, but they are optional here. Dried cranberries give a brighter tart bite. Chopped apples add juicy crunch, though they are best added close to serving so they stay fresh. Cashews or pecans can replace sunflower seeds if nuts are welcome at your table.
For a meatless version, leave out the bacon and add smoked almonds or extra sharp cheddar. The salad will lose some salt, so taste the dressing and add another pinch. If you like a broccoli salad with more fruit and nuts, the Broccoli Cashew Salad with Apples and Pears is a good next bowl to try.
FAQs
- Do I cook the broccoli for Creamy Amish Broccoli Salad?
No. Use raw broccoli and raw cauliflower for the best crunch. Cut the florets small so they are easy to bite and can catch the creamy dressing.
- Can I make Amish broccoli salad the night before?
Yes, but hold back a little bacon for topping if you want it crisp. The salad tastes great after 4-12 hours in the fridge because the dressing has time to season the vegetables.
- Can I use Greek yogurt instead of sour cream?
Plain Greek yogurt works well in place of sour cream. It makes the dressing a little tangier and lighter, so taste before adding the last spoonful of vinegar.
- What can I use instead of raisins?
Dried cranberries, chopped apples, or extra sunflower seeds all work. You can also leave the sweet fruit out and let the sugar in the dressing do the balancing.
- How long does creamy broccoli salad last?
Store it airtight in the refrigerator for up to 3 days. Stir before serving because the dressing can settle at the bottom of the bowl.
- What should I serve with Amish broccoli salad?
It is good with grilled chicken, burgers, pulled pork, baked ham, or picnic sandwiches. It also works beside rich casseroles because the raw vegetables keep the plate fresh.
