South Carolina Bird Dog Sandwiches

When I’m after bold and easy comfort food, nothing hits the spot quite like South Carolina Bird Dogs. These are inspired by that favorite sandwich you’d grab at a Southern snack shack. Toast up a super soft roll, stack on crispy chicken tenders, toss on plenty of tart pickles, slather on creamy mustard-mayo, and finish it all off with tangy mustard BBQ sauce. You get sweet, savory, and a bit of spice in every bite – real down-home goodness.

I got hooked on these gems during a long drive through the Lowcountry one summer. That mix of sharp mustard sauce and juicy chicken totally won me over. Now, we’re always making them for family game nights.

Irresistible Ingredients

• Shredded lettuce or crunchy slaw: Makes it fresh and gives that much-needed crunch; pre-mixed bags make life easier
• Small red onion: A punch of flavor and a bit of mild heat; slice thin so every bite pops
• Golden chicken tenders: Whether you fry, bake, or grill, they’re filling and work with whatever method you like
• Chopped pickles: Get bread & butter or dill for zing and crispness; chop fresh ones for the crunchiest bite
• Soft hoagie rolls or sandwich buns: Acts like a flavor sponge, especially bakery-fresh ones
• South Carolina mustard-style BBQ sauce: That tangy-sweet kick comes straight from quality mustard
• Honey: Gives the sauce a subtle sweetness; local honey adds an extra layer of flavor
• Full-fat mayonnaise: Adds rich, creamy vibes—using the real stuff makes everything taste better
• Hot sauce: Toss on if you like a fiery bite; a few drops transform the whole thing
• Dijon mustard: Brings sharpness; choose smooth or grainy as you like
• Salt and black pepper: Don’t skip them; bring the whole thing together, so go by taste

Simple How-To Steps

Finish Up:

If you’re into spicy food, splash hot sauce over the filling. Cap it off with the other half of your roll and press gently to hold it. Dig in while it’s hot and juicy.

Final Toppings – Pickles and Onion:

Sprinkle chopped pickles all over, then toss on red onion slices. They amp up the tang and bring some crunch.

Crisp Lettuce or Slaw:

Grab a handful of shredded lettuce or slaw and scatter it evenly on top for a cool crunchy layer.

BBQ Sauce Splash:

Drizzle a healthy pour of mustard BBQ sauce over the chicken—you want every bite to have some punch.

Chicken Time:

Layer cooked chicken tenders right onto the sauce-slathered bun. Make sure they fit from end to end.

Sauce Layer:

Spread your creamy mustard-mayo blend thick over the bottom part of the roll. Don’t forget the edges.

Rolls—Get Them Toasty:

Slice the rolls if needed and toast them in the oven (350°F) or a hot skillet until the inside’s crisp but still fluffy, about two or three minutes.

Mix Your Sauce:

Stir mayo, honey, Dijon, salt, and pepper in a bowl. Whisk until smooth. Take a taste and add more salt if you want.

Cook Up Chicken:

Season tenders with salt and pepper. Pan-fry in hot oil for 5–6 minutes at 375°F, or bake at 400°F for 15–20 minutes, turning halfway, or grill on medium-high for about 5–7 minutes a side. Once cooked through, let them rest before putting your sandwich together.

Pin it

That sharp, cold pickle crunch mixed with creamy sauce is my top pick. As a kid, my cousins and I would battle for the last slices. Now I always pile them high, because pickles just make it better.

Keep It Fresh

Stash each part by itself if you’ve got leftovers. Chicken keeps well for three days in the fridge if it’s sealed tight. Store sauce and veggies separately so nothing goes mushy. Warm up the chicken just enough so it stays soft, and toast fresh bread before you build another sandwich.

Easy Swaps

No tenders? Grab some rotisserie chicken or even leftover grilled breast. Out of mustard BBQ? Regular honey mustard or your usual barbecue sauce can step in. Any soft roll or even a brioche bun does the trick for holding all the good stuff.

What to Serve With

These sandwiches are awesome with kettle chips, sweet potato fries, or a pile of homemade slaw. For drinks, nothing beats sweet iced tea or a cold beer out on the patio. Want more kick? Put extra hot sauce or fresh jalapenos on the side.

Pin it

Each bite brings real Southern comfort right to your table. It’s bold, homey, and just makes you feel good.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ What type of chicken works best for these sandwiches?

Boneless chicken tenders are the way to go. Fry, grill, or bake them—whatever makes them crunchy and tasty works great here.

→ Can I use store-bought mustard barbecue sauce?

Definitely, just grab your favorite Carolina-style mustard BBQ sauce from the store for that classic tang.

→ What's the best way to toast the rolls?

Plop the rolls into a hot pan or oven for a few minutes and wait until they're just crisp and light brown.

→ Are there good substitute toppings?

Lettuce shreds, classic slaw, pickled slices, and onion work well, but swap in some tomato or jalapeño if you'd like.

→ How can I adjust the spice level?

A splash of hot sauce will kick up the heat, or just leave it out to keep things gentle.

→ Is this sandwich suited for meal prep?

You can do up the chicken and toppings ahead, then just put everything together right before you eat so it stays crisp.