01 -
Beat softened butter in stand mixer or with electric mixer until creamy.
02 -
Gradually mix in 2 cups powdered sugar on low speed until combined.
03 -
Mix in extracts and salt until well combined.
04 -
Add heavy cream and mix, increasing to medium speed.
05 -
Mix in remaining powdered sugar until playdough consistency. Add coloring if desired.
06 -
Roll into ½-inch logs, cut into small pieces. Place on wax paper-lined sheet.
07 -
Let dry uncovered at room temperature several hours until firm.