01 -
Refrigerate the eggnog, club soda, punch bowl, and glasses until very cold. This keeps the punch creamy and helps the fizz last longer.
02 -
Brush a thin band of honey, corn syrup, or simple syrup around each glass rim. Dip into crushed candy canes and set aside for a few minutes.
03 -
Pour the chilled eggnog into the punch bowl. Add peppermint schnapps now if using. Slowly pour in the club soda and stir gently.
04 -
Scoop the peppermint ice cream over the top of the punch. Let it soften for 1 minute, then stir once or twice so creamy pink swirls remain visible.
05 -
Ladle into the prepared glasses and add a mini candy cane to each serving. Serve immediately for the best texture and fizz.